I was in Washington DC on vacation the week the news media was all a-twitter about some congressman’s crotch shots. I haven’t the slightest interest in wasting time on such things. Some of us consumers of information and entertainment actually have a taste for quality content, and would prefer to find coverage of the decision-making process on bringing troops home from Afghanistan, or the real reasons Republicans feel so threatened about putting Elizabeth Warren in charge of consumer financial protections, or a substantive examination of the various issues comprising health care reform on the front pages of major newspapers. You know, real news.
Maybe acknowledging that much of what the Tea Party movement is belly-aching about was identified and explored by the counter-culture back in the 1960s would kick-start a spirited public dialogue and crowd the trash out to the margins. “Power to the People.” “Small is Beautiful.” “Question Authority.” These are not new ideas. Dressing up in costume and throwing tantrums can be lots of fun, but at best all it can do is influence people in power. The real game is what the adults are doing.
Republicans are the ones who kept bashing Vietnam-era anti-war protesters over the head with the slogan “America: Love It or Leave It,” so what’s with the “Love Your Country, Fear Your Government” stuff that the Johnny Reb-come-latelies are fulminating about? Most of us youthful Baby Boomer lefties got the memo: you’re supposed to grow up and take your place as a responsible, functioning member of society; build long-term relationships; rack up consumer debt in pursuit of your personal vision of the good life (ideally including a mortgage); etc., etc. The American system is far from perfect, but it actually does a pretty good job of offering maximum individual freedom to a highly diverse population. As a woman, I don’t take that for granted.
At DC’s National Portrait Gallery, I wandered through an exhibit that noted the push-pull between the Declaration of Independence’s manifesto on individual liberty and the framework of laws set out in the Constitution. American culture was built from the start on a dance between these polarities. Individual stories play out in infinite patterns, but we’re all bound by the same laws. If we don’t agree with how the system operates, we’re empowered to try to change it. This whole democratic experiment in the idea of self government is a work in progress, and it’s a relatively new development in the global arena.
It’s no small thing that Congressional Republicans have recently started coming around to supporting the anti-war position. I wish they had had their crisis of conscience about fiscal matters back when George W. Bush decided that going to war in Iraq was a good idea and there was no need to worry about the costs, but better late than never. The U.S. has been playing the role of world cop ever since World War II, and we can’t afford it any longer. Europeans have enjoyed significantly better social services over the last half century than Americans because they’ve been able to rely on us to foot the bill for a massive military and provide defense around the globe. Those days are over. The Obama administration has begun making this case in subtle and not-so-subtle ways, including Secretary of Defense Robert Gates’s recent remarks in Brussels that a new generation of American leaders, for whom the Cold War was not a formative experience, is unlikely to continue giving the Europeans a free ride. The times they are a-changin’. Finally.
The Vietnam era culture wars exposed some critical fault lines in how American democracy functions. Since then, a great deal of progress has been made, especially in the realms of personal freedom and equal rights. But we still have a long way to go to make good on the promise of “government of the people, by the people and for the people” that Abraham Lincoln invoked in the Gettysburg Address. The good news is that a majority of Americans genuinely seems to want the system we’re told we have. How we might pool our efforts to make substantive progress towards our shared goals will take a lot of work and discussion. You’d think that process would be more newsworthy than the adolescent antics of yet another ego-challenged politician.